Mr. Coffee Vs. Hamilton Beach Coffee Makers (Things To Consider)

Last Updated on April 5, 2022 by John Moretti

In today’s ever-growing coffee culture, there are countless ways to make coffee. Each brewing method has its advantages and disadvantages, and the choice at the end of the day comes down completely to personal preference. While some will opt for the more complicated methods, others prefer the simplest ways of brewing their daily cuppa.

Both Mr. Coffee and Hamilton Beach are brands that produce several different coffee makers. They are predominantly your typical drip-type filter coffee machines that brew a simple jug of hot coffee for easy, everyday enjoyment. Each machine has its advantages and disadvantages with subtle differences between the brands.

While both brands produce several coffee makers, there are some distinct differences between the two brands that may sway your decision in either direction, depending on what you want from a coffee maker. Whichever option you decide to go with, rest assured you will be purchasing a good quality machine that will serve your everyday coffee needs for years to come.

Mr. Coffee Vs. Hamilton Beach Coffee Makers

Mr. Coffee and Hamilton Beach are two brands that have been trusted for ages to brew a simple yet fulfilling pot of coffee every day for their users. Both brands produce good quality coffee makers that effectively brew decent coffee, and the machines themselves are available at an affordable price point.

Certain machines within the range of each brand are the most popular, and so this article will focus on comparing the characteristics of a few of the favorite machines from each manufacturer.

Generally speaking, Mr. Coffee’s machines are far simpler than Hamilton Beach coffee makers in terms of their functionality and usability and are generally also cheaper to purchase as a result.

Hamilton Beach Coffee Makers tend to have more features than those machines produced by Mr. Coffee and offer more customization options. These features can be overwhelming to those users who simply want to make an average jug or cup of coffee.

Certain features are certainly advantageous such as automatic turning off, auto-pause functionality, programmable brewing, and the option to brew a single cup when needed.

When it comes to a coffee machine, there are several qualities one must compare in order to ensure the coffee is up to the desired standard of the user. At the end of the day, you want your coffee maker to produce coffee that is consistently enjoyable to drink and won’t disappoint you on a daily basis.

Consistency is, therefore, an important consideration for a coffee machine, along with ease of operation and intuitive programming.

Qualities To Compare In Coffee Machines

When comparing Mr. Coffee’s Machines with the Hamilton Beach Coffee Makers, one must consider the machine’s ability to produce consistent coffee. Included in this is also the machine’s ability to maintain consistent temperatures, as any significant fluctuations in temperature will adversely affect the coffee’s quality and taste.

Ease of operation is another important consideration that can be a major deciding factor. Some users of coffee machines desire only to have a simple machine that they can operate without needing a manual. This is especially important during the early hours of the morning before you’ve had your first cup of coffee.

The physical footprint of the coffee machine is another important consideration that may determine your choice, especially if you have a small kitchen with limited counter space. 

Programming your coffee machine should be intuitive and should not generally require the use of an owner’s manual in order for you or your guests to use the machine. Brewing time should also be considered, as you generally want your machine to brew a jug of coffee within a reasonable period.

One should also consider the number of cups of coffee the machine is able to brew at once, as well as the machine’s ability to keep warm the leftover coffee. Whether the carafe is made out of glass or metal will also play a role in this.

Mr. Coffee 12 Cup Coffee Maker

The Mr. Coffee 12 Cup Coffee Maker is one of the brand’s most popular machines for several reasons. Firstly, this machine is extremely affordable, allowing consumers to make a good cup of coffee at home for an extremely affordable price. 

Secondly, the machine is extremely easy to use and will not require you to bring out the owner’s manual in order to brew a simple jug of coffee. One of the major benefits of this machine is its dual water windows that allow you to see how much water is in the machine from whichever angle you look at it.

This coffee maker boasts a simple interface with a simple on/off function while simultaneously featuring an auto-pause option that allows you to remove the jug while brewing is still occurring. This will allow you to pour a single cup of coffee without waiting for the entire jug to be complete.

One downside of this machine is the fact that it does not have the ability to turn off automatically, meaning that a jug of coffee sitting on the warmer will continue to warm up if left unattended.

Hamilton Beach Flexbrew

The Hamilton Beach Flexbrew is, for the most part, a simple coffee maker but boasts a few added features. This machine allows you the option to either brew an entire jug of coffee or to brew a single cup when necessary using a K-cup

This means that the machine not only saves on time and coffee grounds if you only need to brew a single cup, but it allows you to use the machine for making tea and hot chocolate using the K-cup attachment.

This coffee maker also allows you to adjust the strength of your brew and features and an auto-off function that can be extremely helpful. Being able to program the machine to brew a jug of coffee at a specific time is another added benefit that makes this machine an excellent choice.

Hamilton Beach 46310

The Hamilton Beach 46310 is another popular machine that allows you to adjust the size of the brew between one and four cups of coffee. 

There are several other features for the user’s convenience, including a water tank that is accessible from the front, an outward swinging filter basket (also to the front) as well as a hot plate that turns off after two hours, preventing scorched coffee.

Mr. Coffee Vs. Hamilton Beach Coffee Makers


Your choice of coffee machine between Mr. Coffee and Hamilton beach comes down to personal preference at the end of the day. If you prefer a simpler machine that does what it needs to and no more, Mr. Coffee might be the brand for you. 

If you’re looking for a slightly more sophisticated coffee maker at a slightly higher price that potentially produces higher quality coffee, Hamilton Beach might be your preferred brand.

The difference between the quality of coffee produced by the two brands is generally small (except to the coffee connoisseur), so you will be assured of a good, simple cup of coffee, whichever brand you decide to choose.