Last Updated on May 24, 2022 by John Moretti
Generally speaking, espresso machines tend to be far more complicated than they appear at first glance. Any coffee lover will tell you that in order to brew the perfect cup of coffee or pull the perfect shot of espresso, several factors must all be perfectly balanced. Arguably the most important factor is the water itself.
Water affects the taste and quality of coffee in every way. Therefore, the coffee must be properly filtered to ensure there are no contaminants and that the water itself possesses the ideal minerals needed to create the perfect coffee. Ion exchange resin and charcoal filters perform these roles, respectively.
The two different types of filters perform completely different roles in water filtration. Still, each is equally as important as the other. While the two differ drastically, they function best when combined to create the best possible water for your espresso.
Ion Exchange Resin Vs. Charcoal Filter For Espresso Machine
While the Ion exchange resin and the charcoal filter for an espresso machine are technically both filters, they differ completely in terms of both their purpose and their methods. Ion exchange resin essentially prevents scaling and alters the hardness of the water to ensure the correct mineral content for making coffee.
On the other hand, Charcoal filters are specifically designed to filter out and remove certain unwanted elements found in water to improve the taste and overall health of the water.
Essentially, the role of the ion exchange resin is to soften the water to a certain degree, ultimately protecting the machine itself from damage caused by scale build-up. On the other hand, the charcoal filter exists to filter out contaminants, removing bad tastes, odors, bacteria, organic materials, chlorine, and lead.
While the charcoal filter removes contaminants and retains them, keeping them out of the water, the ion exchange resin reacts with the compounds in the water, ultimately changing its structure and, therefore, its hardness.
The charcoal filter also helps prevent the escape of any beads from the soft casting that would otherwise tend to find their way into the machine.
Charcoal Filters Explained
Carbon (or charcoal) filters are manufactured using carbon-rich organic materials such as bamboo or coconut shells. The materials are then broken down into tiny pieces. These small pieces of carbon, either grains or blocks, are treated to become extremely porous.
The porosity is to increase the surface area by a significant amount, thereby boosting the substance’s ability to absorb the highest possible amount of contaminants from the water.
As the water flows through the charcoal filter, the chemicals, and other contaminants essentially stick to the carbon, removing it from the water, resulting in purer water overall.
The contaminants and chemicals removed from the water will naturally vary according to what is found in the water in that specific region and the ability of the specific filter to remove certain chemicals. Therefore, it’s important to establish the chemicals before deciding which type of charcoal filter will be best for your circumstances.
On average, charcoal filters can remove between sixty and eighty chemicals completely from the water. They can also reduce the concentration of around thirty chemicals while moderately reducing the presence of a further twenty-two.
The chemicals and contaminants usually removed from the water used in espresso machines are predominantly pesticides, organic contaminants, and herbicides. The removal of these contaminants is important not only for the taste of the coffee but also to ensure the consumer’s health is protected.
Charcoal filters are also responsible for removing unpleasant flavors, odors, small particles, chlorine, bacteria, lead, and organic materials. By removing all of the above from the water, you can be assured of clean water free of any contaminants that can potentially ruin your favorite brew.
Chlorine, as mentioned above, can often create a strong flavor in the water. Unfortunately, chlorine is a highly present chemical in tap water because it ensures that drinking water is safe from contamination. The need for chlorine is more significant in some areas than in others, so the amount of chlorine in drinking water can differ across the country.
Ion Exchange Resin Explained
Ion exchange resin filters are generally manufactured with a long column filled with polymer resin beads. The reason for the small beads is that they allow for a more significant surface area to come into contact with the water as the water moves past the beads.
Ion exchange resins generally exist for the purpose of altering the water’s hardness. The hardness of the water generally refers to the level of certain minerals present in the water, specifically calcium and magnesium.
Water that contains high levels of these minerals is considered hard water and is not ideal for making coffee. Therefore, something to reduce the levels of the minerals (and therefore the water’s hardness) is essential.
This is where ion exchange resins come into play. The process of ion exchange refers to capturing unwanted ions in the water while replacing them with a preferable alternative. In the case of hard water, meaning water with high levels of calcium and magnesium, the ion exchange resins work as follows:
The resin will essentially replace the positive ions of calcium and magnesium with sodium. The negative ions of sulfate or carbonate are simultaneously replaced with chloride. The end result? Softer water is ideal for making coffee.
It’s interesting to note that the sodium and the chloride tend to get used up as time passes and will therefore need to be replaced. This is a simple process of soaking the resin in a solution of sodium chloride concentrate.
While ion-exchange resin filters and charcoal filters differ drastically in terms of their respective purpose, both filter types are extremely important for ensuring that the water used in your coffee is of the best possible quality.
These two filters work best in combination, with one adjusting water hardness while the other removes all possible contaminants from the water.